SAN DIEGO, Calif. — Stetson Football concluded its 2026 season Saturday evening at Torero Stadium, falling to San Diego 59-21 in the regular-season finale. The Hatters found the end zone in each of the first three quarters, highlighted by touchdown receptions from Kingston McCullough and Shawne Jones, but the Toreros used a 28-point second quarter and a balanced offensive attack to pull away.
The Hatters (1-11, 0-8 PFL) finished with 252 yards of total offense, including 234 through the air, while San Diego (6-5, 5-3 PFL) accumulated 586 yards and controlled possession for 39:36. Stetson completed 24 of 40 passes without an interception, but the Toreros' rushing attack proved difficult to contain, producing 317 yards and five touchdowns.
Freshman wide receiver Kingston McCullough caught six passes for 76 yards and a touchdown, while junior Shawne Jones led the Hatters with eight receptions for 94 yards and a score. Senior captain Wyatt Rogers added five catches for 41 yards and contributed 111 yards on six kickoff returns.
Quarterbacks Chris Stephenson and Kael Alexander both saw significant action, combining for 234 passing yards and two touchdowns. Stephenson completed 10 of 15 attempts for 130 yards and scored Stetson's opening touchdown on a 4-yard run, while Alexander went 14-for-25 for 104 yards and two passing touchdowns.
Defensively, Shug Bentley led the Hatters with 12 tackles, including six solo stops. Freshmen Dylan Kelly and Eli Durden added seven tackles apiece, while Kyle Elphick, Damontez McDowell and Lemuel Bass each finished with six.
Stetson's defense opened the contest with an important stop after San Diego moved into Hatter territory on its opening possession. The Toreros advanced to the Stetson 32-yard line, but Alex Yearwood helped bring down Omar Mbakwe on fourth-and-2, forcing a turnover on downs and giving the Hatters their first offensive opportunity.
After the teams traded punts, Stetson began another possession at its own 16-yard line and moved the chains on a 17-yard completion from Stephenson to Rogers. San Diego regained possession moments later when Sean Scheck sacked Stephenson and forced a fumble that Tim Hays recovered at the Stetson 24. Following a penalty, Adam Criter scored on a 12-yard run to give the Toreros a 7-0 lead with 4:06 remaining in the opening quarter.
The Hatters answered with one of their most sustained drives of the evening, marching 75 yards in 12 plays. Stephenson connected with Jones for 21 yards and Rogers for nine before breaking free for a 17-yard run that moved Stetson to the San Diego 4-yard line. After consecutive incompletions, Stephenson kept the football and scored on third down with 22 seconds remaining. The extra-point attempt was blocked, leaving the Hatters trailing 7-6 after the first quarter.
San Diego extended its advantage early in the second quarter, completing a 69-yard drive with a 1-yard touchdown run from quarterback Dom Nankil at the 11:59 mark. The Toreros added another score midway through the period when Nankil connected with Cole Monach for a 15-yard touchdown, increasing their lead to 21-6.
Stetson responded with an explosive three-play, 79-yard possession that showcased McCullough's ability to generate yards after the catch. Stephenson opened the drive with a 31-yard completion to the freshman receiver, and a pass interference penalty helped move the Hatters farther into San Diego territory. McCullough followed with a 32-yard reception that advanced the ball to the 1-yard line before Alexander connected with him for the touchdown. Paul DeSousa added the extra point, bringing Stetson within eight at 21-13 with five minutes remaining before halftime.
The Toreros answered with two touchdowns in the final three minutes of the half. Criter scored from one yard out with 2:43 remaining, and after San Diego regained possession following a turnover on downs, Nankil found Monach for a 32-yard touchdown with 34 seconds left. The late scores gave the Toreros a 35-13 advantage entering the break.
Stetson received the second-half kickoff but was unable to establish a sustained drive, and San Diego followed with an 11-play, 70-yard possession that consumed just over five minutes. Zamar Reese capped the series with a 6-yard touchdown run, extending the Toreros' lead to 42-13 with 8:41 remaining in the third quarter.
The Hatters responded with another productive possession, covering 60 yards in five plays. Alexander connected with Rogers for a 9-yard gain on third down, helping Stetson move into San Diego territory, before a defensive pass interference penalty advanced the ball to the Toreros' 41-yard line. On the next play, Alexander found Jones for a 41-yard touchdown reception. Anthony Benzija completed a pass for the two-point conversion, bringing the score to 42-21 with 6:50 remaining.
San Diego quickly regained momentum after Stetson's ensuing onside kick attempt left the Toreros with favorable field position. Nankil directed a four-play, 39-yard scoring drive, connecting with Monach for a 9-yard touchdown with 5:25 remaining in the quarter. The score marked Monach's third touchdown reception of the evening and gave San Diego a 49-21 advantage.
Stetson continued to move the football on its next possession, with Alexander finding McCullough for a 19-yard gain to move the Hatters near midfield. The drive eventually ended on downs, however, and the Toreros carried their advantage into the fourth quarter.
San Diego added a 46-yard field goal from Emiliano Salazar early in the final period before Criter broke free for a 77-yard touchdown run with 9:33 remaining. The Toreros' defense held Stetson scoreless in the fourth quarter, and San Diego maintained possession for the final 8:04 to secure the 59-21 victory.
Criter finished with 194 rushing yards and three touchdowns on 23 carries, while Monach caught nine passes for 127 yards and three scores. Nankil completed 19 of 26 passes for 237 yards and three touchdowns while adding a rushing score.
Saturday's contest marked the conclusion of Stetson's second season under head coach Mike Jasper. The Hatters will now turn their attention to the offseason and preparations for the 2027 campaign.
Hatters Top Performers
Shawne Jones — Wide Receiver
- Team-high eight receptions for 94 yards
- Caught a 41-yard touchdown pass in the third quarter
- Averaged 11.8 yards per reception
Kingston McCullough — Wide Receiver
- Six receptions for 76 yards and a touchdown
- Hauled in a 1-yard touchdown reception in the second quarter
- Added gains of 31 and 32 yards during Stetson's second-quarter scoring drive
Chris Stephenson — Quarterback
- Completed 10 of 15 passes for 130 yards
- Scored on a 4-yard touchdown run in the first quarter
- Helped lead a 12-play, 75-yard touchdown drive
Kael Alexander — Quarterback
- Completed 14 of 25 passes for 104 yards
- Threw two touchdown passes without an interception
- Connected with Shawne Jones for a 41-yard touchdown in the third quarter
Wyatt Rogers — Wide Receiver / Kick Returner
- Five receptions for 41 yards
- Six kickoff returns for 111 yards
- Finished with 152 combined receiving and kickoff return yards
Shug Bentley — Linebacker
- Team-high 12 tackles
- Six solo stops and six assisted tackles
- Helped anchor Stetson's defensive effort in the season finale
Dylan Kelly — Defensive Back
- Seven total tackles, including four solo stops
- Added a tackle for loss and a pass breakup
Eli Durden — Linebacker
- Seven tackles, including four solo stops
- Recorded one tackle for loss
Game Notes
- Stetson concluded its 2026 season with a 1-11 overall record and an 0-8 mark in Pioneer Football League play, while San Diego finished 6-5 overall and 5-3 in conference competition.
- The Hatters scored touchdowns in each of the first three quarters, finishing with 21 points and 252 yards of total offense.
- Shawne Jones recorded eight receptions for 94 yards and a touchdown, bringing his season total to 10 receiving touchdowns.
- Freshman Kingston McCullough finished with six catches for 76 yards and a touchdown, recording his second touchdown reception of the season.
- Chris Stephenson and Kael Alexander combined to complete 24 of 40 passes for 234 yards and two touchdowns without an interception.
- Wyatt Rogers recorded 111 yards on six kickoff returns and added five receptions for 41 yards in his final collegiate game.
- Shug Bentley led the Hatters with 12 tackles, his second double-digit tackle performance of the season.
- Stetson scored on both of its red-zone opportunities and finished with three touchdowns, including two passing scores and one rushing touchdown.
- The Hatters converted 4 of 11 third-down attempts, while San Diego finished 14-for-18 on third down.
- San Diego accumulated 586 yards of total offense, including 317 rushing yards and five touchdowns on the ground.
- Saturday marked the conclusion of Stetson's 2026 regular season and its second campaign under head coach Mike Jasper.